smiley trade compensation

[enduro]

hey hawkes fans

Guard smiley is being traded to your hawkes and i was wondering if anyone heard what the other end of the trade is? draft pick, player ???

MERGED: Rumor/Report - Dolphins looking to trade Smiley - Miami Dolphins Fans, News, Salary Cap, Forums

Report: Smiley is on the trade block | ProFootballTalk.com

what are you going to give us??????

 

[SeahawkWag]

with his huge injury problems (can't stay healthy) I'd say 5th rounder.

 

[SeahawkWag]

lol just read Miami wants a 3rd rounder.......... uh no. If we take on a risk and a contract it would have to be a 5th or later

 

[enduro]

lol just read Miami wants a 3rd rounder.......... uh no. If we take on a risk and a contract it would have to be a 5th or later

ok I could live with a 4th. he is a very good guard when healthy. He's good for at least 8 games a year.

 

[miamiron]

ok I could live with a 4th. he is a very good guard when healthy. He's good for at least 8 games a year.

Greetings from sunny Miami,
Your team needs offensive line help and with Smiley you will get just that.

Smiley has missed 13 games in 6 nfl seasons
which if you compare to some of your players on the offensive line is an improvement.

We want to give you Smiley and swap #1 draft picks
what else would it cost to complete this deal?

thanks,
MiamiRon

 

[Hawk096]

I don't see this deal being made for a 3rd-round pick. We just traded to San Diego our third-rounder in 2011 and with his age he's not worth a 3rd-round pick. I could see a 4th-round pick and possibly a compensation pick in 2011, but I don't think Seattle is trying to get older. Yes he would be an improvement over some of our guys, but his age won't help us at all. Given the trades we've been making it seems we want to get younger. I haven't heard anything about a trade between the two being finalized. I do know we lost DE Cory Redding to Baltimore today.

 

[SeahawkWag]

Greetings from sunny Miami,
Your team needs offensive line help and with Smiley you will get just that.

Smiley has missed 13 games in 6 nfl seasons
which if you compare to some of your players on the offensive line is an improvement.

We want to give you Smiley and swap #1 draft picks
what else would it cost to complete this deal?

thanks,
MiamiRon

:suicide_fool-edit:

 

[SeahawkWag]

oh wait you wanted to swap your 12 for our 14

fair deal

 

[dmarkholt12]

Greetings from sunny Miami,
Your team needs offensive line help and with Smiley you will get just that.

Smiley has missed 13 games in 6 nfl seasons
which if you compare to some of your players on the offensive line is an improvement.

We want to give you Smiley and swap #1 draft picks
what else would it cost to complete this deal?

thanks,
MiamiRon

Do you mean you want to swap your 12 for our 14? Because if you mean your 12 for our 6 then there is no way this deal will ever take place. But if you wanted to swap your 12 for our 14 then i say we give you one of our 4th rd picks. The guy is a risk because he is injury prone. Ya when healthy he is very good, but like hawk96 said we are trying to get young and healthy. I dont see you getting much for him...4th rd pick at most.

 

[Fenom]

I'd give them a 4th round pick. If they decline, I'd throw in the other 4th round pick the Hawks have.

 

[dmarkholt12]

I'd give them a 4th round pick. If they decline, I'd throw in the other 4th round pick the Hawks have.

you would give them 2 4th rd picks for a guy that is injury prone?

 

[Fenom]

you would give them 2 4th rd picks for a guy that is injury prone?

I'd give both 4th round picks if I knew Sims/Spencer weren't coming back. But, if I knew they both were coming back I'd only offer them one 4th round pick.

 

[SeahawkWag]

is it done? they are saying press conf Tue (miami side)

 

[dmarkholt12]

I'd give both 4th round picks if I knew Sims/Spencer weren't coming back. But, if I knew they both were coming back I'd only offer them one 4th round pick.

i hear ya i just dont think giving away 2 4th rd picks is a good idea for a guy that has a past of injuries. i realize that they are 4th rd picks, but in this years draft those are good picks. this is a very deep draft class. not to mention that would give the hawks 0 picks in the 3rd and 4th rounds...a lot to give up for a guy that could very well only play half the year or not even.

 

[szat]

I say give them our 2nd round (60 now) for in trade for spencer/sims for their tenders. :emoticon-0129-call:

 

[Hawk096]

The Dolphins Press Conference may have to do with the latest arrest of Ronnie Brown.

 

[Pottsie]

Justin Smiley played @ Alabama... he was great @ SF, didn't hear much about him in Miami... I'd personally like to have him for depth. 5th rounder in return.